Dielectric and Microwave Properties of Graphene Nanoplatelets /Carbon Black Filled Natural Rubber Composites

Natural rubber (NR) based nanocomposites containing a constant amount (50 phr) of standard furnace carbon black and graphene nanoplatelets (GNP) in concentrations from 1 to 5 phr have been prepared. Their dielectric (d ielectric permittiv ity, dielectric loss) and microwave propert ies (coefficients of absorption and reflect ion of the electromagnetic waves and electromagnetic interference shielding effectiveness) have been investigated in the 1-12 GHz frequency range. The results achieved allow us to recommend GNP as second filler for natural rubber based composites to afford specific absorbing properties.


Introduction
Significant scientific and technological interest has focused on carbon -polymer nanocomposites over the last two decades. The specific develop ment of poly meric nanocomposites based on conventional poly mers and conductive carbonaceous materials has drawn much attention as a route to obtain new materials with new structural and functional properties superior to those of the pure components that find applications in many industrial fields. Control of the size, shape and surface chemistry of the reinforcement materials are essential in the develop ment of materials that can be used to produce devices, sensors and actuators based on the modulation of functional properties as [1]. At present, nanocomposites employing carbon-based reinforcement materials are do minated by carbon nanotubes (CNTs) as [2][3][4]. However, the development of CNT-reinforced composites has been impeded by both their difficu lt dispersion in the polymer matrix and their h igh cost.
The discovery of graphene [5] and the subsequent develop ment of g raphen e -based po ly mer n anoco mpos it es is an important addition in the area of nanoscience and technology. Graphene is an allotrope of carbon, whose structure is one-atom-th ick planar sheets of sp 2bonded carbon atoms packed in a honeycomb lattice. It is the basic structural element of some carbon allotropes including graphite, charcoal, carbon nanotubes and fullerenes [6].
Co mpared to carbon nanotubes, as well as its high aspect ratio and low density graphene has attracted considerable attention because of its unique and outstanding mechanical, electrical and electronic properties (e.g. exceptional in -plane electrical conductivityup to ~ 20,000 S/cm and highest thermal conductivity -up to ~ 5,300 W/ mK).
All these unique properties in a single nanomaterial have made physicists, chemists and material scientists exited about graphene's potential. The history, chemistry, preparation methods and possible applications of graphene are reviewed in [7][8][9]. Another new review focused on trends and frontiers in graphene-based polymer nanocomposites was published an year ago [10]. Recently, the trustees of Princeton University received a patent for graphene-elastomer nanocomposites where functionalized graphene sheets had been dispersed in vulcanized natural rubber, styrene butadiene rubber, Ps-isoprene-Ps and Polydimethylsilo xane (PDM S) [11]. The authors concluded that graphene-rubber nanocomposites possess qualities like those of carbon nanotube composites but are much cheaper to make. Nanostructure material might be one of the most promising materials to enhance the EM wave absorption ability owing to its higher surface area, mo re surface ato ms, mu ltireflection, and thus larger d ielectric or/and magnetic loss. Co mbination of poly mers and nanomaterials is able to integrate the large electric/ magnetic loss of inorganic materials and the easy tenability of poly mer and is possibly an optimal strategy to design excellent EM wave absorption materials.
Lately the research works appear about a possible applications of nanocomposites based on elastomeric matrices and carbon nanotubes as filler in microwave absorbers for deciding of electro magnetic interference (EMI) and electromagnetic co mpatibility (EM C) problems [12][13][14][15][16][17][18][19][20][21]. The polymer matrices used in these cases are usually epoxy resin, acrylonitrile-butadiene rubber, styrene-butadiene rubber, silicone rubber, polyurethane rubber. Co mparat ively it is rare to find out investigations on nanocomposites based on natural rubber (NR) and carbon nanotubes and this is in the last years [22][23][24][25].
The data about graphene influence on the micro wave properties of the elastomeric co mposites are very scarce. Y. Chen et al. used functionalized graphene-epoxy composites as lightweight shielding materials for electro magnetic radiation [26]. I. M. De Rosa and co-workers have a wide expertise in the design of micro/nanocomposites based on carbon fibers and carbon nanotubes, for the realizat ion of high performing radar absorbing screens, with tailored properties [27][28][29]. In a recent paper [30], the authors have accomplished a Salisbury screen that consists of three layers. The second layer (the spacer) is a lo w-loss-tangent nanocomposite based on a Bisphenol-A based epoxy resin filled with g raphene nanoplatelets (GNPs) at 0,5% and 1 wt %. The real and imaginary parts of the co mplex effective permittivity within the 8-18 GHz range of the nanocomposite filled with GNPs have been shown. It has been observed that the real part of the effect ive permittivity is nearly constant.
The price of GNPs is still significantly h igher than standard furnace carbon black. In this context, the aim of this study is to determine whether the addition of small quantities (1-5 phr) GNP to one standard significantly greater amount of active furnace carbon black (50 phr) can be used as a way to modify and control, primarily to imp rove the dielectric (dielectric permittivity, dielectric loss) and microwave properties (coefficient of reflection, coefficient of attenuation, electro magnetic interference shielding effectiveness) of composites based on natural rubber in the high frequency range 1-12 GHz. Data for such a study of those combinations of fillers that we ment ioned was not found in the literature.

Characterization of the Graphene used
Graphene produced by Hayzen Engineering Co., Ankara, Turkey was used in our investigation ( Figure 1). Graphene nanoplatelets (GNP) have a "platelet" morphology, meaning they have a very thin but wide aspect ("sheet"-like structure). Aspect ratios for this material can range into the thousands. Each particle consists of several sheets of graphene with an overall thickness of 50 nm and average plate diameter 40 microns. The pattern taken in SAED regime shows a co nsiderable nu mber of spot-like reflect ions typical for single-crystal structures (Figure 1 -in the right angle).

Characterization of Carbon Bl ack used
The specific structure features of carbon black used (Corax N 220, produced by Evonik) are shown in Figure 2.
It can be seen that the primary particle size of the carbon black used is about 20 n m, but their capability to form secondary aggregates and agglomerates is considerable. SA ED indicates the absence of crystal structures.

Preparati on and Vulcanizati on of Rubber
Compounds /Carbon Black Filled Natural Rubber Composites Table 1 su mmarizes the formu lation characteristics of the rubber compounds (in phr) used for the investigations. The rubber compounds were prepared on an open two-roll laboratory mill (L/ D 320х360 and friction 1.27) by incorporating pre-characterized CB and GNPs into a natural rubber matrix at various loadings ( Table 1). The speed of the slow ro ll was 25 min -1 . The experiments were repeated for verify ing the statistical significance. The ready co mpounds in the form of sheets stayed 24 hours prior to their vulcanization.
The optimal vulcan ization time was determined by the vulcanizat ion isotherms, taken on an oscillating disc vulcameter M DR 2000 (A lpha Technologies) at 150 o C according to ISO 3417:2002.
These composites were evaluated for their dielectric (d ielectric permitt ivity, dielectric loss angle tangent) and microwave (reflection coefficient, attenuation coefficient, shielding effectiveness) properties in the 1-12 GHz frequency range.

Reflect ion and Attenuation
Measurements of reflection and attenuation were carried out using the measurement of output (adopted) power P a in the output of a measuring line without losses, where samples of materials may be included. Because of the wide frequency measurement a coaxial line was used. Samp les of the materials were shaped into discs with an external diameter D=20.6mm, equal to the outer diameter of the coaxial line and thickness of mm 2   . The internal diameter depended on the relative dielectric permittivity of the material.
The sample reflected a part of the incident electro magnetic wave with power P in . The rest of the wave with power P p penetrated the material, so that the attenuation L depended on the coefficient of reflect ion |Г |. Its module was determined by a reflect meter. Thus the attenuation was determined by dB P P L p a , log 10  The following scheme presents the equipment used for testing both parameters (Figure 3 This parameter is defined as the sum of the reflection losses R,dB and attenuation L,dB in the material [31].It can be directly measured or calculated fro m the measured reflectance and attenuation in the material. In the first case, as measured: incident power on the sample P in, and adopted after the sample P a , S.E. is determined by .   (4) where R, dB is the attenuation due to the reflection of power at the interfaces.
In the present work the shielding effectiveness was determined by equation (4).

Co mp lex Permitt ivity
The determination of co mp lex permittiv ity was carried out by the resonance method, based on the cavity perturbation technique [32].
Having measured the resonance frequency of the empty cavity resonator f r a measurement of the shift in resonance frequency f ε was carried out in the presence of the sample material. Then the dielectric constant ε r was calculated fro m the shift in resonance frequency, cavity and the sample cross sections S r and S ε , respectively The sample was in the form of a disc with a diameter of 10 mm and about 2 mm thick. It was placed at the maximu m electric field location of the cavity. Because the thickness of the sample was not equal to the height of the resonator, a dielectric occurred with an equivalent permitt ivity ε e at the place of its inclusion. The parameter was determined by (5) and instead ε r be saved ε e . Then ε r was determined by where   / l k and l is the distance fro m the d isc to the top of the resonator.

Loss Factor tan δ
The loss factor tan δ was calculated fro m the quality factor of the cavity with Q ε and without sample Q The measurement setup used several cavity resonators for the whole range, generators for the whole range, frequency meter and oscilloscope.
The following scheme presents the set used for measuring the dielectric properties ( Figure 4

Co mp lex Permitt ivity
The dependence of the real part of co mp lex dielectric permittiv ity (the so-called relat ive dielectric permitt ivity ε r ) on the frequency and amount of the second filler is shown in Figure5. It can be seen from the graphs that with the increase of frequency and amount of the second filler (GNP) at constant amount of carbon black (50 phr), the values of relative dielectric permitt ivity increase. The influence of the frequency and amount of the second filler is significantly pronounced in the range 7-12 GHz and the values of ε r are between 3.2 and 3.8.
The polarization mechanis m operating in the gigahertz frequency is purely electronic or orientational with relaxation times smaller than the time period of the applied signals. Interfacial polarization, which is the basic reason for the dispersion in dielectric permittivity at radio frequency regime, has no role to play in microwave frequencies as it does not produce dispersion in ε r because of its much smaller relaxation time. But ε r was found to increase with the increase of phr of graphene nanoplatelets in the composite as it is evident from Figure 5. Th is phenomenon of increase in dielectric permittiv ity with the increase in second filler concentration can be attributed to the enhancement of electrical conductivity of the composites. We consider it was due to graphene, because we have observed similar alterations in the natural rubber based composites with graphene as a filler [33].

Dielectric Loss
The dependence of the imaginary part of the complex d ielectric permitt ivity (dielectric losses) on the amount of the second filler and the frequency at constant amount of the first filler is shown in Figure 6.
With the increase of frequency, the dielectric losses decrease, but by increasing the amount of the second filler (GNP) the losses increase. The values of tan δ are between 1.7.10 -3 and 13.10 -3 .  The dependence of the coefficient of reflection of electromagnetic waves on the frequency and amount of the second filler is shown in Figure 7.

Coefficient of Reflection
It can be seen from the graphs that with the increase of frequency and amount of the second filler, the reflection coefficient also increases and reaches 0.79 value when n=5 and f=12 GHz. The influence of the amount of GNP is stronger compared to the influence of frequency.

Coefficient of Attenuation
The dependence of the coefficients of attenuation on the amount of the second filler and frequency is shown in Figure  8. It is obvious that with the increase of the amount of the second filler and frequency the coefficient of attenuation also increases. When the amount of GNP is higher (e.g. at 5 phr, the attenuation coefficient of co mposites is in the range of 22-39 d B/cm).

Shielding Effectiveness
The dependence of the shielding effect iveness on the amount of the second filler and the frequency is shown in Figure 9. The decrease in the values of this characteristic depending on frequency is quite obvious since the growth of the coefficients of attenuation is apparently not high enough to make up for the increase in reflection coefficients. These two coefficients according to equation (4) are crucial to the formation of the value of the shielding effect iveness. It was found out that the percolation threshold for co mposites filled with the investigated fillers, but individually and not in combination, is at 12 and 15 phr respectively for GNP and CB [34]. It is possible because GNP and CB have different geometry (the values of aspect ratio for CB is 1 and for GNPfro m 120 to 200). According to Balberg [34] the average interparticle d istance can be different in the carbon nanofillers with different aspect ratios. The more spherical-like structure, the larger the interpart icle distance will be formed. For the elongated particles, their co mposites have a very narrow d istribution of the distances due to the entangled particles structures [35] and the volu me resistivity of the composites decreases monotonically with increasing the aspect ratio. The interpart icle distance, composites microstructure and the volume resistivity have a strong influence on the micro wave properties [36]. Presumably the increase of the dielectric permittivity of the co mposites, containing GNP and carbon black toward high frequencies is induced by the dielectric relaxation which suggests that the established percolation network structure is not stable and easily affected by the external frequency disturbances.
Our investigations present that adding small amounts (1-5 phr) of GNP to a standard constant amount of active furnace carbon black can be used as a way to modify and to improve the dielectric (d ielectric permittiv ity, dielectric loss) and micro wave properties (coefficient of reflect ion, coefficient of attenuation, electromagnetic interference shielding effectiveness) of natural rubber based composites in the high frequency range 1-12 GHz.

Conclusions
NR based nanocomposites containing a constant amount of standard furnace carbon black and GNP in concentrations fro m 1 to 5 phr have been prepared. Their dielectric (d ielectric permittiv ity, dielectric loss) and microwave properties (coefficients of absorption and reflection of the electromagnetic waves and electro magnetic interference shielding effectiveness) have been investigated in the 1-12 GHz frequency range. It was found effect of modifying the properties of the composites. Adding small amounts of GNP to a constant amount of carbon black can be used as a way to control and primarily to imp rove the dielectric and microwave properties of co mposites based on natural rubber in the high frequency range 1-12 GHz. The results achieved allow us to recommend graphene as second filler fo r natural rubber based composites to afford specific absorbing properties.