Determination of Aflatoxin Levels in Some Dairy Food Products and Dry Nuts Consumed in Saudi Arabia

Three hundred and ninety-three samples of dairy products (124 samples of white cheese, 61 samples of cream cheese, 76 samples of Kashar cheese, and 132 samples of butter), 91 samples of cashew nut and 97 macademia nut marketed in Eastern Province, Saudi Arabia during September 2010-September 2011, were analyzed for aflatoxin M1 (AFM1), total aflatoxin and AFB1 by microtitre plate enzyme linked immunosorband assay (ELISA) The incidence of AFM1 contamination in dairy products analyzed was 82%. Total aflatoxin contamination was determined in 84 (92.3%) of 91 cashew nut and in 88 (90.7%) of 97 macademia nut whereas total aflatoxin contamination was not detected in 3 (3.2%) of 91 cashew nut samples and in 12 of 97 macademia nut samples. AFB1 was found in 84 (92.3%) of 91 cashew nut and in 83 (85.5%) of 97 samples of macademia nut samples. AFM1 levels in 3 (2.4%) white cheese, 4 (3.0%) of butter, 2 (3.2%) in cream cheese and 5 (6.5%) of Kashar cheese samples were found higher than the maximum acceptable levels as set by European Union.Continuous surveillance program may be warranted to monitor regularly the occurrence of aflatoxins in foodstuffs.


Introduction
Incidences of food contamination have become increasingly frequent in recent years raising question about their human health and economic consequences. Aflatoxins (AFs) are highly toxic secondary mould metabolites. Mycotoxicoses, which can occur in both industrialized and developing countries, arise when environmental, social and economic conditions combine with meteorological conditions (humidity, temperature) which favor the growth of moulds. Aflatoxins are a group of structurally related toxic compounds produced by certain strains of the fungi Aspergillus flavus, which produce only B aflatoxins and Aspergillus parasiticus which produces both B and G aflatoxins. The major aflatoxins of concern are designated B1, B2, G1 and G2. These toxins are usually found together in various foods and feeds in various proportions. Aflatoxins M1 and M2 are oxidative metabolic products of aflatoxin B1 and B2 produced by animals and is usually excreted in the milk, urine and faces of dairy cattle and other mammalian species that have consumed aflatoxin-contaminated food or feed. Aflatoxicol is reductive metabolite of aflatoxin B1 (Kumar et al, 2008;Bakirci, 2001;Galvano, Galofaro, & Galvano, 1996;Galvano et al. 2001; Kotsonis, Burdock, & Flamm, 1996;Stubblefield & Shannon, 1974). Many researchers reported that there was a linear relationship between the amount of AFM1 in milk and AFB1 in feed consumed by the animals (Bakirci, 2001).
The most pronounced contamination has been encountered in the tree nuts, peanuts, and other oil seeds, including corn and cottonseed. Therefore, data on the occurrence of aflatoxins in foods and feeds are needed to enable exposure assessment and estimate the effects of regulatory limits. AFM1 may or may not be present in dairy products in a particular year depending on the weather conditions for that period. Hence, widespread and frequent monitoring should be carried out (Galvano et al., 1996). Aflatoxins are acutely toxic, immunosuppressive,mutagenic, teratogenic and carcinogenic compounds. The main target organ for toxicity and carcinogenicity is the liver (Aflatoxins Milk and milk products are a major nutrient for human especially children. However, at the same time these products may be contaminated with AFM1 resi-dues, a human health hazard. For this reason, many countries have regulations to control the levels of aflatoxin B1 in feeds and to propose maximum permissible levels of AFM1 in milk to reduce this risk ( Sarımehmetoglu et al., 2004). The European Commission have set limits for maximum levels of total aflatoxin and AFB1 allowed in groundnuts, nuts, dried fruit and their products. For foods ready for retail sale, these limits are 4 µg/kg (total aflatoxins) and 2 µg/kg (AFB1), and for nuts and dried fruit to be subjected to sorting, or other physical treatment, before human consumption or use as an ingredient in foodstuffs the limits stand at 10 µg/kg (total aflatoxins) and 5 µg/kg (AFB1). The EU Commission legal limits for AFM1 in milk, butter and cheese are 0.05 µg/l (Codex Alimentarius Commission, 2001; Commission Regulation, 2002; Turk Gda Kodeksi Teblig, 2002). Saudi Arabia is the largest consumer of dry fruits in the GCC. On the other hand, dairy products have been produced and consumed widely in Saudi Arabia. Purpose of this study was to determine occurrence and levels of aflatoxins in some dairy products and dry fruits consumed by Saudi people.

Materials and Methods
A total of 124 samples of white cheese, 61 samples of cream cheese, 76 samples of Kashar cheese, 132 samples of butter (393 dairy products) and 91 samples of cashew nut and 97 samples of macademia nut (total 188 samples) were obtained randomly from markets in Eastern Province were analyzed from September 2010 to September 2011 and aflatoxin concentrations were determined by enzyme linked immunosorband assay, ELISA (Ridascreen, aflatoxin M1-rbiofarm) in our laboratories. All samples were collected and analysed before their expiration dates exceeded. The samples were analysed as procedure which described by R-Biopharm GmbH (Enzyme immunoassay for the quantitative analysis of aflatoxins, 1999). Immunoaffinity columns were used for samples (RIDA-Aflatoxin column-r-biopharm) clean up prior analysis of aflatoxin M1 and B1 levels in dairy products (cheese and butter) and dry fruits (cashew nut and macademia nut). The basis was antigenantibody reaction. The column contained a gel suspension to which monoclonal antibodies were attached covalently. The antibodies were specific for the aflatoxin B1 and M1 (Figures 1 & 2).
For aflatoxin M1 analysis, 2 g of samples and 40 ml dichloromethane were used for extraction. The suspension was filtered and a 20 ml extract was evaporated under nitrogen. The extraction procedure was repeated with 0.5 ml phosphate buffered solution (PBS) and 1.0 mL heptane and centrifuged for 15 min at 2500 rpm and 15℃. The methanol layer was used for AFM1 testing. Detection limit was <10 ppt.
For total aflatoxin analysis, 2.0g of sample was weighed into a screw-top glass vial. Ten milliliter methanol/distilled water (70/30) was added and mixed by using shaker for 10 min at room temperature (20-25 C). Extract was filtered by using Whatman 41filter paper, 100 µL of the filtrate diluted with 600 µL of sample dilution buffer and 50 µL of diluted filtrate was transferred per vial in the assay. The mean recovery rate has been determined to be 85% with a coefficient of variation of 15%.  Similarly, for aflatoxin B1 analysis, 2.0 g of sample and 7 ml methanol (100%) were used for AFB1 extraction (shacked for 10 min). Two milliliter of filtrate was transferred into a screw-top centrifugal vial, 2 ml distilled water and 3 ml of dichloromethane were added and mixed for 5 min and centrifuged for 5 min/3250 rpm/15℃. The upper aqueous layer was removed and entire dichloromethane layer was used. The dichloromethane layer was evaporated at 50-60℃. The extraction procedure was repeated with 0.4 ml PBS and 1.5 ml heptane as depicted above. The upper heptane layer was removed and the methanol layer was used for AFB1 testing. Detection limit was 625 ppt and recovery rate was 50-70%.

Results and Discussion
In this study, AFM1 contamination in the dairy products (cream cheese, butter, white cheese and Kashar cheese) was  (15.3%), white cheese, in 5 (6.5%) Kashar cheese, and in butter 41 (31.0%) samples (Table 1). AFM1 levels in 3 (2.4%) white cheese, 4 (3.0%) of butter, 2 (3.2%) in cream cheese and 5 (6.5%) of Kashar cheese samples were found higher than the maximum acceptable levels (cheese: 250 ng/kg, butter: 50 ng/kg) of the Turkish Food Codex in 183 sample of white cheese and butter in Istanbul in 2001 and incidence of AFM1 in white cheese and butter samples were found as high as 65% and 81%, respectively. Dagoglu et al. (1995) analysed 75 white cheese samples and AFM1 contamination was 42%. Gunsen and Buyukyoruk (2003) analysed 86 fresh Kashar cheese for AFM1 and 28 (32.5%) of samples exceed allowed limits. These results were higher than reported in the present study. Pietri, Bertuzi, and Piva (1997) checked 223 samples of Grana Padano cheese manufactured in 4 years (1991)(1992)(1993)(1994) and it has emerged that only one sample exceeded the maximum tolerated level in cheese in some European countries (250 ng/kg). Most samples (91%) were found in the range 5-100 ng/kg and only 15 (6.7%) was found in the range 100-250 ng/kg. Abdulkadar et al. (2000) analysed edible nuts for aflatoxin contamination which imported in Qatar between June 1997 and December 1998. Eighty-one nut samples were analysed in the second half of 1997 and contamination was detected in 19 samples with total aflatoxin varied from 0.53 to 289 lg/kg. Aflatoxin B1 levels in common Egyptian foods was determined by reversed-phase liquid chromatography with UV detection and the highest prevalence of AFB1 contamination was found in nuts and seeds (82% of 17 samples) ( It is likely that a level set as low as this will have an impact on world trade and so it is important that society, both producers and consumers, is confident that it is justified. Clearly, any risk assessment of a naturally occurring toxic compound must be based on information about occurrence, exposure and toxicology (Moss, 2002).
In conclusion, AFM1 incidence in cream cheese, butter, white cheese, and Kashar cheese was found high. In addition, AFB1and total aflatoxin occurrence in the most of cashew nuts and macademia nut were also detected. Finally, the results of the present study clearly show the need of periodically monitoring the occurrence of aflatoxin in dairy products and dry nuts.